This veteran NASA astronaut has tried SpaceX and Boeing's new spaceships — here's what she thinks

After nearly a decade of effort, SpaceX and Boeing are preparing to launch the first NASA astronauts on commercial spaceships.

Advertisement

On August 3, NASA announced the first nine astronauts who will risk their lives on the first crewed missions of Boeing's CST-100 Starliner and SpaceX's Crew Dragon spacecraft in 2019.

The goal of NASA's Commercial Crew program, as it's called, is to taxi astronauts to and from the $150-billion International Space Station (ISS). Accomplishing that would close an increasingly expensive gap in the US' space-travel capabilities.

sunita williams astronaut sunglasses commercial crew nasa 27997318958_f14805fe3a
NASA astronaut and Commercial Crew member Sunita Williams in March 2018. NASA/Kim Shiflett

In 2015, NASA selected astronaut Sunita "Suni" Williams and three other "space pioneers" to test then fly the new spaceships.

Williams is slated to fly aboard Boeing's second test flight to the ISS.

Advertisement

"Five years ago, this would have been like, 'No way, what are we doing asking commercial providers to be able to do this?'" Williams told Business Insider in June. "Now it feels like a natural progression for space travel."

Williams has flown inside three spaceships, served as commander of the International Space Station, lived in orbit for 322 days, and piloted 30 different types of aircraft for the Navy.

This extensive resume has come in handy over the past three years, as Williams has worked closely with Boeing and SpaceX. She and her colleagues have poked and prodded spacecraft mock-ups, tried on new spacesuits, fiddled with control panels, tested out simulators, and provided frank and sometimes critical feedback.

Here's why NASA needs Boeing and SpaceX, what Williams thinks of their new ships and suits, and how she's preparing to blast off into the uncharted territory of a new space race.

Advertisement

This story was updated with new information. It was originally published on June 24, 2018.

Advertisement

Williams said she and the rest of the "Commercial Crew Cadre," as they're called — astronauts Doug Hurley, Eric Boe, and Bob Behnken — have worked "hand-in-hand" with Boeing and SpaceX since being assigned to the program by NASA in 2015.

commercial crew nasa astronauts kennedy space center spacex 41831881141_ca5d81940c_k
NASA astronauts who will be the first to fly inside SpaceX's Crew Dragon. Left to right: Doug Hurley, Eric Boe, Bob Behnken, and Sunita Williams. SpaceX

NASA announced that those four astronauts would be some of the first to fly crewed missions for Boeing and SpaceX, along with five others: John Cassada, Chris Ferguson, Victor Glover, Mike Hopkins, and Nicole Mann.

nasa astronauts commercial crew program august 2018 AP_18215584667709
Left to right: Glover, Hopkins, Behnken, Hurley, Mann, Ferguson, Boe, Cassada, and Williams. David J. Phillip/AP

Source: Business Insider

Advertisement

NASA started the Commercial Crew program to replace its space shuttles. The cost of shuttle launches was high: Each mission cost about $1.5 billion, including development costs, and 14 astronauts died. The 135th and final mission launched in July 2011.

space shuttle atlantis sts135 july 2011 copyright dave mosher
Space shuttle Atlantis at Launchpad 39A in Cape Canaveral, Florida. Dave Mosher

Source: Nature

So when NASA sent Williams to the International Space Station (ISS) in 2012, the agency had to buy her a seat on a Russian Soyuz spaceship. To this day, Soyuz is still the only spacecraft able to journey to and from the ISS.

suni williams astronaut iss crew expedition 32 training russia nasa 9397364074_bb165f9bc2_k
Sunita Williams trains inside a Russian Soyuz TMA-05M spaceship in July 2012. NASA/Victor Zelentsov
Advertisement

Russia has used its monopoly to drive up Soyuz flight prices. In 2011, a round-trip ticket cost about $22 million; today, it costs NASA about $81 million to fly one astronaut.

Soyuz TMA 19M rocket launch nasa
Russia's Soyuz TMA-19M rocket launches a crew of three toward the International Space Station on December 15, 2015. NASA/Joel Kowsky

Source: Business Insider

In anticipation of this pickle, NASA started a competition to encourage companies to build their own spaceships. Boeing and SpaceX came out on top. "Competition is positive. It makes people do things a little smarter, potentially a little faster," Williams said.

sierra nevada dreamchaser spaceplane nasa 36124837514_23353e9c81_k
Sierra Nevada's Dream Chaser spacecraft in an aerodynamic test as part of NASA's Commercial Crew program. NASA
Advertisement

Boeing has earned about $4.8 billion in government contracts and awards for its work on the program since 2010, while SpaceX has earned about $3.1 billion. Boeing's CST-100 Starliner can carry seven people, which is as many as the space shuttle.

boeing cst 100 starliner spaceship capsule illustration nasa
An illustration of Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spacecraft. Boeing

SpaceX's Crew Dragon can also seat up to seven space-flyers and last seven months at the space station.

spacex crew dragon spaceship nasa commercial crew program illustration 42878298755_a9670c6596_o
An illustration of SpaceX's Crew Dragon, also known as Dragon 2 or Dragon V2, orbiting Earth. (The first Dragon was a cargo and supply ship not designed to carry people.) Kennedy Space Center/SpaceX via Flickr
Advertisement

Williams' path into the seat of the CST-100 Starliner began in December 2006, when she made her first flight into orbit aboard space shuttle Discovery.

suni williams astronaut spacesuit portrait nasa 9401781521_5f498352e4_k
A portrait of NASA astronaut Sunita Williams in a bulky External Mobility Unit (EMU) spacesuit in September 2004. NASA

She lived and worked aboard the International Space Station with two Russian cosmonauts, returning home on space shuttle Atlantis in April 2007.

suni williams iss crew expedition 15 9410989364_6555f41832_k
The crew of the Expedition 15 space station crew. Left to right: NASA astronaut Sunita Williams; cosmonauts Fyodor Yurchikhin and Oleg Kotov. NASA
Advertisement

Williams says her initial work on Commercial Crew was mostly PowerPoint presentations and discussions. Only in the past year and a half have astronauts started working with simulators and real hardware. "It's been hot and heavy in the last six months," she said.

crew dragon v2 capsule spacecraft spacex flickr 24159153709_e480e05061_k
A test of SpaceX's Dragon v2 capsule thrusters. SpaceX/Flickr (public domain)

Models of the spaceships that will launch astronauts are now nearing completion or undergoing testing.

cst 100 starliner construction boeing 40344798004_b13216d6f6_k
The state of construction for Boeing's first CST-100 Starliner spaceship in March 2018. Boeing
Advertisement

The controls are one huge difference Williams has noticed when comparing the Crew Dragon and Starliner to older spaceships. "The space shuttle was just littered with switches," she said. "You look at the cockpit, and there's switches everywhere."

space shuttle endeavour flight deck cockpit controls reuters RTR31K04
"The way we described the space shuttle was that there were about 3,000 switches inside and there was no situation the astronauts couldn't make worse by touching the wrong button at the wrong time," Behnken said during NASA's announcement on Friday. "We're grateful that the next vehicle that we're going to fly on is going to be a little bit more automated." Pierre Ducharme/Reuters

SpaceX's Crew Dragon and Boeing's Starliner simplify that labyrinth into a few glowing screens and buttons. "That just makes things easier, and makes things a little bit more changeable," Williams said. "Upgrades can happen a little bit easier, because it's software."

SpaceX crew dragon 3
SpaceX says Crew Dragon's displays "will provide real-time information" on anything ranging "from Dragon's position in space, to possible destinations, to the environment on board." SpaceX
Advertisement

Physical switches are mostly absent in the new spacecraft, since their computers, sensors, and algorithms automate most tasks, especially tedious ones. But Williams says she and the crew felt Boeing and SpaceX's ships showed them too little on-screen information, at least initially — and told the companies as much.

sunita williams control panel simulator screens boeing cst 100 starliner 2 nasa 26573068352_f87421cc90_k
Sunita Williams uses a Boeing CST-100 Starliner display trainer. NASA/Dimitri Gerondidakis

"Automation can help us, but then you do have to watch out," Williams said. "We talked to the both partners about: How do I check this? I have a timeline in front of me — how do I know these things are happening? Where do I check? Where do I look? What's my confirming cue?"

centaur engine upper stage ula boeing cst 100 starliner nasa 29066559015_996fc37e8d_k
The Commercial Crew Cadre examine an RL10 rocket engine that Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spaceship will use. NASA/Dimitri Gerondidakis
Advertisement

"The big thing is you want to keep situational awareness. You don't want to be fat, dumb, and happy in there and something bad's going on," she said.

spaceX crew dragon 4
A spacesuit-clad person inside a mock-up of SpaceX's Crew Dragon looks up at the capsule's buttons, switches, and digital displays. SpaceX

"Then when something is not going as planned, you know how to at least get the vehicle to a safe state," she added. "We can then talk to mission control in Hawthorne or here in Houston and say, 'Hey, what do we do next, and how do we handle this problem?'"

commercial crew dragon rescue practice ocean sunset spacex d41027792664_f4f6b2226d_k
Air Force personnel train to rescue astronauts from SpaceX's Crew Drago spaceship. NASA Langley Research Center/Ron Beard
Advertisement

Williams says physical switches and buttons help ensure that astronauts can control a spacecraft in an emergency, such as loss of power. "It is a spacecraft, and there are some things that have to happen whether or not the electrons are flowing," she said.

astronaut eric boe commercial crew nasa spacex boeing KSC 20170223 PH_SPX01_0002
NASA astronaut Robert "Bob" Behnken tests SpaceX's Crew Dragon spaceship mock-up on Feb. 23, 2017. NASA

"There will be some manual capabilities just to ensure safety and mission success," Williams added.

spaceX crew dragon interior
Buttons and switches shown below digital displays in a mock-up of SpaceX's Crew Dragon capsule. SpaceX
Advertisement

These manual capabilities include "things that you really, really, really want to happen in case everything else dies," such as the deployment of parachutes for landing, Williams said.

crew dragon parachute drop test mojave desert spacex 40221640865_e1c0271292_k
SpaceX performs a parachute test for its Crew Dragon spaceship. SpaceX

Of course, every spaceship needs a spacesuit to protect astronauts if air starts leaking from the ship, or there's some other emergency. Williams said Boeing's and SpaceX's suits are similar to the Sokol suits, which Russia designed for its Soyuz capsule.

suni williams astronaut russian sokol soyuz spacesuit 9401290529_0a100feba2_k
Sunita Williams dons a Russian Sokol spacesuit in March 2007. NASA
Advertisement

The Sokol "is an awesome suit," Williams said. But she noted that the new SpaceX and Boeing designs "look a little bit better" and are more comfortable, thanks to newer materials.

spacex astronaut spacesuit crew dragon 38796771514_a81072e6b8_o
The spacesuit and Crew Dragon spaceship that SpaceX will use to launch NASA astronauts into space. SpaceX

"The SpaceX one has like a motorcycle helmet that comes down and in clips in easy," she said. "An outer cover layer makes the suit look a little bit more slim-lined."

spacex flight spacesuit crew dragon elon musk instagram
A model of a Crew Dragon spacesuit and capsule. Elon Musk/SpaceX; Instagram
Advertisement

The CST-100 Starliner suit takes a different approach. "The blue suit that Boeing has, it has a zipper in the front that'll accommodate a straighter posture" when pressurized with air, Williams said.

boeing starliner spacesuit flickr nasa kennedy 31677349444_6e2f278490_k
Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spacesuit being worn by Eric Boe. NASA Kennedy/Flickr

Each suit is designed to keep astronauts tucked into their seat in a reclined position, which provides extra safety during launch, a hard landing, or a crash.

spacesuit test reclined boeing cst 100 starliner 34848028516_f88c733bfd_k
A crash-test dummy helps an engineer test the safety of a seat for Boeing's CST-100 Starliner. Boeing
Advertisement

"You're going to land essentially on your back," Williams said. "You want to be able to take that impact."

boeing cst 100 starliner landing test 36707592013_11024e8bbe_k
A Boeing CST-100 Starliner spaceship prototype during a landing test. NASA Langley Research Center/David C. Bowman

"Soyuz has seats that are molded to every body to help with the landing," she added. "Both of these companies have seats that keep that in mind."

boeing starliner spacesuit flickr nasa kennedy 32141925730_e7ee67f419_k
Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spacesuit. NASA Kennedy/Flickr
Advertisement

"They're both different, and they're both better than suits that we've had in the past," Williams said. "It's gonna be fun to put a new spacesuit on."

sunita williams nasa astronaut commercial crew dragon mockup spacesuit spacex 28557696438_67cdda2282_k
Williams tests mock-ups of SpaceX's Crew Dragon spaceship and spacesuit in April 2018. SpaceX

Getting into and out of each spacecraft's 3-foot-by-3-foot door isn't easy. "You climb in the door, you can't just walk in," Williams said. "The door is small because you don't want a humongous door that goes out to space." (The bigger the opening, the greater the risk of leaks and other problems.)

spacex dragon spacecraft GettyImages 494548549
A guest explores the Crew Dragon spacecraft in 2014 during its debut by SpaceX. Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images
Advertisement

Though SpaceX's and Boeing's spaceships are roomier than a Soyuz, it's still pretty cramped. "You sort of feel like you're crawling around," Williams said. "It will feel like there's enough space when we get up into space. It helps when you can float and move away from things."

SpaceX crew dragon interior
Each SpaceX Crew Dragon capsule will have four windows and seats made of high-grade carbon-fiber composites. SpaceX

The seat designs aren't finalized, so Williams has yet to see how comfortable they will be. "I haven't seen any leather seats yet," she said, joking. "You're going to be sitting on it or strapped into it; the thing it has to do is provide you protection."

crew dragon v2 capsule spacecraft spacex flickr 21119686299_f3e74431dd_k
The interior of SpaceX's Crew Dragon capsule showing seats for five astronauts, though the craft can support up to seven. SpaceX/Flickr (public domain)
Advertisement

As for a bathroom? "There's limited amount of toilet-type stuff in there. There's a way to go for both companies, but it's not the best," she said.

commercial crew astronauts spacesuit test cst 100 starliner boeing 42755325691_2bdf288b4f_o
Astronauts train inside a mock-up of Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spaceship. Three people — Boe, Ferguson, and Mann — will fly its first test mission. Boeing

"The best thing is probably waiting till you get to the space station," Williams added.

sunita williams astronaut smiling happy spacesuit nasa 9397330196_6b8a365de9_k
NASA astronaut Sunita Williams smiles in her spacesuit in January 2011 while training for spaceflight. NASA
Advertisement

The Commercial Crew program will launch uncrewed ships first, one per spacecraft, then follow up with two crewed flights each to the International Space Station.

crs 14 spacex falcon 9 dragon launch space station cargo april 2 2018 26326005987_c04418a784_k
SpaceX's CRS-14 mission launches cargo toward the International Space Station on April 2, 2018. SpaceX/Flickr (public domain)

Source: Business Insider

"We've gotten into the cockpit in both spacecraft. We've run through parts of the profile, from launch to rendezvous docking, un-docking, and [atmospheric] entry. But everything's not been tied up, not quite yet," Williams said. She didn't say which company's spaceship is her favorite.

spacex commercial crew dragon test chamber nasa 42761063191_50dfcc6168_k
SpaceX's Crew Dragon spaceship undergoes testing for electromagnetic interference in a special chamber. SpaceX
Advertisement

Crewed launch dates may slip deep into 2019. Williams says it will take about a year from now to complete mission training. Also, Boeing discovered a fuel leak with Starliner — the system Williams is to fly — which delayed its first crewed flight as a result.

crew dragon illustration iss space station docking spacex 25097984792_0711b57aa7_k
An illustration of SpaceX's Crew Dragon spaceship docking with the International Space Station. SpaceX

Source: Business Insider

SpaceX is aiming to do its uncrewed flight in November and Boeing in December. If successful, SpaceX may launch its first crew in February 2018 and Boeing in mid-2019. A second crewed flight will follow to fully certify each system.

boeing cst 100 starliner docking space station illustration space earth 24062224484_39cd846e51_k
An illustration of Boeing's CST-100 Starliner docking tot he International Space Station. Boeing

Source: Business Insider

Advertisement

NASA originally wanted crewed launches to happen by 2017, but delays snowballed due to the agency's stringent safety concerns. It wants Boeing and SpaceX's spacecraft to have less than a 1-in-200 chance of killing a crew in an accident — three times less than the space shuttle.

commercial crew certification nasa 42209238132_03cb0d945e_k
Kathleen O'Brady, a NASA certification systems engineer, reviews documents for Boeing and SpaceX's new spacecraft. NASA/Frankie Martin

Source: Business Insider

"There will be what's called flight readiness reviews for all of these flights, and people will look at the risks," Williams said. "There'll be some explaining to do if there's any outstanding risk that hasn't been at least discussed and looked at and weighed."

launchpad emergency egress boeing cst 100 starliner 33430258710_96e507b73b_k
Engineers test a zip line that may help NASA's Commercial Crew astronauts escape from a launchpad in an emergency. NASA/Leif Heimbold
Advertisement

Williams and her colleagues are clear-eyed about the risk they're taking. In fact, two of them — Behnken and Hurley — were on the runway waiting for space shuttle Columbia's landing when they heard it had broken apart during atmospheric reentry.

space shuttle columbia sts 107 crew nasa sts107 s 002
A portrait of NASA's STS-107 mission crew members, who died in the space shuttle Columbia disaster on February 1, 2003. NASA

Source: Aviation Week

"Spaceflight is inherently dangerous. Something that we've never thought of could potentially happen," Williams said.

space shuttle cahllenger disaster accident wreckage nasa
A piece of wreckage recovered from the Jan. 28, 1986 space shuttle Challenger disaster. NASA
Advertisement

"This is our profession and this is what we're supposed to do. I think everybody will be up to the challenge and ready to go when the spacecraft are ready," she said. "Everybody believes, or they wouldn't be here, that what we're doing is for a bigger purpose."

suni williams astronaut spacesuit training communication nasa 9394563439_bddac04787_k
Sunita Williams positions a communications headset during training in September 2011. NASA

NASA has a little more than a year to certify either spaceship system, or it risks temporarily losing access to the space station. There are enough Soyuz flights to last NASA through the fall of 2019, but Russia wants three years of notice to prepare new missions.

soyuz russia roscosmos spaceship nasa
A three-module Soyuz spacecraft. NASA

Source: Business Insider(1, 2)

Advertisement

NASA is building its own rocket and spacecraft, called Space Launch System, but that program won't fly its first astronauts until June 2022 at the earliest.

illustration space launch system rocket orion spaceship assembly hangar nasa
An artist's depiction of NASA's Space Launch System and Orion spaceship being assembled in a hangar. NASA

Source: NASASpaceflight.com

Overall, Williams said the International Space Station program is a model for "working with people that you weren't necessarily really friends with at one point in time." She added: "Russian cosmonauts are itching to fly on these spacecraft as well, and those are the ultimate signs of trust: We go jump in a Soyuz, we trust these guys to do the right thing, and they trust us as well."

sunni williams yuri malenchenko aki hoshide iss expedition 32 33 flags crew russia nasa 9394592213_3e7a8500f6_k
NASA astronaut Sunita Williams (right), Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) astronaut Akihiko Hoshide (left), and Russian cosmonaut Yuri Malenchenko (center) before launching to space together in 2012. Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center
Advertisement

"We're trusting these companies to do the right thing as well," she said. "All that collaboration, all that sharing of technology and information, and understanding each other along the way, I think those are hugely important and it's going to help us continue to explore."

suni williams nasa astronauts commercial crew program august 2018 AP_18215607165249
Williams waves after her Aug. 3, 2018 selection to fly on the second crewed mission of CST-100 Starliner, a spaceship that Boeing designed and built for NASA. David J. Phillip/AP

Williams said she's met with Elon Musk multiple times and discussed his hopes and dreams. "I'm hoping along the same lines that he is, that all of this type of stuff opens spaceflight to many, many, many more people," she said. "I feel like it's almost on the verge, like when aircraft went commercial."

elon musk spacex dragon capsule spaceship AP_16274646362043
SpaceX founder Elon Musk in front of a Dragon capsule model. Associated Press
Advertisement

"I think he understands that this program needs to be successful so that people all around the world would be happy to get in one of his spacecraft," Williams said of Musk. "The technology is there. It's time, and I'm hoping in our lifetime we see more people go to space and eventually somebody to Mars."

mars colonization bfr spaceship elon musk spacex iac 2017 talk
Reusable spaceships might enable SpaceX to colonize Mars. SpaceX/YouTube

Correction: A previous version of this story cited target launch dates for Boeing and SpaceX's demonstration missions that differ from NASA's Commercial Crew website. Those dates have been clarified and updated with the best information available as of August 3, 2018.   

SpaceX Boeing NASA
Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.